Captain's Quarters Blog

« Osama Weighs In | Main | Kerry Flip-Flops Within The Same Speech On OBL »

October 29, 2004
Scripps Howard Presents Ludicrous Analysis Of OBL Tape's Effect

Lisa Hoffman at Scripps Howard News Service attempts to write a balanced view of the effects that the new Osama bin Laden missive will have on our upcoming election. Reprinted by the Minneapolis Star Tribune for tomorrow's paper, Hoffman's analysis emphasizes that Islamic terrorists feel that George Bush has been "good for business", and winds up in left field:

In fact, critics of the war in Iraq and other U.S. foreign policies say, the Bush tenure has actually been a boon for bin Laden.

Those bent on global Islamic holy war see the U.S. president as the personification of arrogance and imperialism - a tailor-made poster boy for recruiting jihadis across the globe. Just because they vilify him doesn't mean they want him evicted from the White House.

"If you ask them if they are better off now than they were four years ago, (Islamic extremists) would say the past four years have been very good," said Joseph Cirincione, senior associate at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace in Washington. "There isn't an Islamic fundamentalist alive who wouldn't say (Bush) has been big for business."

Trying to figure out who OBL prefers in our election is a fool's errand, and apparently Scripps Howard found a fool to write this so-called analysis as well as a few for resources. Asking the CEIP for an objective outlook would be equivalent to asking Michael Moore for an unbiased review of the campaign. Cirincione belongs to that class of idiots who think that Islamic fundamentalism began on 9/10/2001 and has been caused by George Bush.

Al Qaeda had launched several large-scale attacks on America and others during the 1990s while no one lifted a finger to stop them. They had a complex and effective financing network funnelling hundreds of millions of dollars to them. They had one nation, Afghanistan, which openly supported and sheltered them and had implemented their idea of governing on 24 million unfortunate Afghanis. They operated with impunity in scores of countries, including ours, and attacked at whim.

Three years after 9/11, we've captured or killed most of their leadership and a large number of their associates, negating Cirincione's supposed boon for recruitment. We've dismantled a large part of their financial network, cutting of a large part of their income. We removed the Taliban, liberating Afghanistan and allowing them to get rid of oppressive, radical Islamist totalitarianism in favor of a democratic government. We cut Southwest Asia in two by toppling Saddam Hussein, eliminating a transit point between Afghanistan, Iran, Pakistan, and Syria, Lebanon, and the West Bank. We convinced Pervez Musharraf to fight the Islamists, making their former safe haven of Pakistan a dangerous place for them to live.

Is this how Bush has been big for Islamist business?

Osama doesn't care who gets elected, or if he does, it is a secondary consideration. He's more interested in intimidating Americans as a whole and leveraging our fear into a foreign-policy change that cuts off our alliance with Israel and a general withdrawal from the ummah. OBL 'prefers' Kerry only in the sense that OBL is a member of the Anyone But Bush contingent.

The new tape has positive and negative effects on both candidates, as I wrote earlie, and those probably cancel each other out. It helps Kerry in proving that OBL is still alive, and Bush because it reminds people that we are under attack and have to quit pretending that the war is over, or that it amounts to nothing more than an organized crime ring. Both sides will make of that what they will this weekend. However, to offer an analysis that pretends the last four years have been wonderful for Islamofascists stretches credibility far past the breaking point, and both Scripps Howard and the Strib should be embarassed to publish it.

Sphere It Digg! View blog reactions
Posted by Ed Morrissey at October 29, 2004 6:49 PM

Trackback Pings

TrackBack URL for this entry is

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Scripps Howard Presents Ludicrous Analysis Of OBL Tape's Effect:

» The return of Osama from Commonwealth Conservative
Well, Osama is back, and just in time for the election. Surprised? There has been some speculation about whether the return of Osama is good news for either candidate politically. My take is that it is slightly better news for Bush, at least ele... [Read More]

Tracked on October 29, 2004 9:27 PM

Design & Skinning by:
m2 web studios

blog advertising


Proud Ex-Pat Member of the Bear Flag League!