Captain's Quarters Blog

« Dissent In North Korea: AP | Main | Still Whining After All His Tears »

January 18, 2005
The Silence Of The Cheese

Can you still hear the cheese screaming, Clar-iiiiiice?

Michelle Malkin points out a story that I had missed in neighboring Wisconsin, one that calls into question the veracity of its presidential-election results. Wisconsin wound up going for John Kerry by 11,300 votes in what came as a mild surprise to most observers in the Upper Midwest (via Stranded On Blue Islands). Al Gore had carried the state by a shade over 5,000 votes in 2000, and most pollsters had the race a dead heat or George Bush pulling slightly ahead in 2004. Instead, Kerry took Wisconsin by doubling Gore's margin.

How did that happen? Well, in one county -- Milwaukee, a traditional Democratic stronghold -- turnout increased by just under 49,000 votes, or about 10%, outstripping the nationwide increase of 6.4%. The new votes broke about 60/40 Kerry, about the trend of the county in both elections, adding a 9,000-vote margin to Milwaukee over Gore in the last election.

But here's where the Silence Of The Cheese gets ... well, stickier. According to state records, 83,000 people executed a same-day registration for Milwuakee County, which is more than 20% of all voting-age residents in the county. Now, Wisconsinites may procrastinate a bit, but in order to believe that number, you'd have to expect that 20% of the county had moved or became newly eligible within the past two years (after the previous national cycle). Not only that, but the state now reports that 10,000 of those registrations cannot be verified, a whopping 12% of all same-day registrations and almost the entire margin of victory for Kerry for the entire state.

Two more interesting statistics show up as well. In 2000, the US Census Bureau showed that Milwaukee County had 425,990 residents 18 years of age and older (incorrect -- see below), yet the 2000 election had 433,537 voters casting ballots. In order for that to be correct, the census had to miss 2% of Milwaukee's 18+ population -- and no felons had to live in Milwaukee County, nor any resident aliens, illegal aliens, or any other adult ineligible to vote. And that's just 2000. In 2004, again, the voters increased by 11% on top of what was already a 102% turnout for the previous presidential election.

But hey, let's be fair about this. Maybe those statistics are in error and Milwaukee has always turned out big in elections, although 113% does seem a bit high, even for civic-minded Wisconsin. Take a look at 1996, when Bill Clinton coasted to re-election over Bob Dole. Milwaukee was no exception either; Clinton topped Dole by a shade over 97,000 votes. The difference is that Milwaukee only cast 365,387 votes for president that year (page 52), or about an 86% turnout. That's 68,000 less than 2000 and a whopping 117,000 less than 2004.

Did Milwaukee grow that much? Or has Mayor Daley been resurrected in Milwaukee?

Despite being the fastest-growing metropolis for likely voters in the nation and despite its razor-thin margin for John Kerry, the Wisconsin voting irregularities have yet to grab the attention of the national media. Instead of long lines due to the miscalculations of Democratic Party election officials in Ohio who were too cheap to buy enough voting machines, we appear to have endemic voter fraud in Wisconsin's largest county, large enough to have returned fraudulent Electoral College results in two succeeding presidential elections. And yet Barbara Boxer has shed no tears on the Senate floor for Wisconsin voters; John Kerry has not pontificated in stentorian tones about Wisconsin disenfranchisement on Martin Luther King Day. The New York Times has not called for a federal investigation into Milwaukee's double-plus-good turnout the past two presidential elections. CBS News has not delivered a breathless report on it for 60 Minutes Wednesday. In fact, from what I can find, not one national news outlet has given any attention to the facts above. Not one.

Why? Why does the Silence Of The Cheese continue to deafen our national media? If they have their way, Clarice Starling wouldn't come within 500 miles of Milwaukee but instead would chase down red herrings in Cleveland, Ohio. It almost convinces me that political bias plays a role in mainstream media coverage. Good think Dick Thornburgh told me otherwise.

UPDATE: Welcome, Instapundit readers! Be sure to read these blogs for more details:

The American Mind
Boots and Sabers
Pull On Superman's Cape

UPDATE II: I misread the data from Stranded On Blue Islands. The correct number for Milwaukee County adults in 2000 was significantly higher -- 692,339. SOBI referenced data for Milwaukee City, while I compared that to county returns. That moves the 1996 turnout to 57% of all adults (not registered voters!), 2000 to 62.5%, and 2004 to 69.7%, although the raw voter totals remain correct in my post above. My apologies; I should have confirmed that data first as it does materially affect the analysis.

However, the growth rate for Milwaukee County is almost a 20% increase in voters over an eight-year period. Does that sound like Milwaukee has grown that fast? Especially when the Census Bureau shows a net decrease in population for Milwaukee of 36,000 by 2003 (estimated)? That includes a net decrease in adults of 29,000...

UPDATE III: I've been asked why I didn't just rewrite this post with the correct data. Well, I assume that some people might be able to find the original post through RSS feeds, so that would look rather dishonest -- and besides, I screwed up, and I don't have an issue with admitting it. The new data changes this from a slam dunk to a more complicated story. I've taken a fresh look at the correct demographic data in this new post, and I hope you check it out.

Sphere It Digg! View blog reactions
Posted by Ed Morrissey at January 18, 2005 5:20 AM

Trackback Pings

TrackBack URL for this entry is

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference The Silence Of The Cheese:

» Voting Irregularities In Wisconsin? from Jay
Captain Ed takes a look at the results of the Presidential elections in Wisconsin and finds some rather iffy numbers coming from the Badger State. Given that Bush was expected by many to win Wisconsin by a narrow margin, the fact that Kerry outperforme... [Read More]

Tracked on January 18, 2005 8:08 AM

» Have the Dictacrats Struck Again? from MartiniPundit
It truly boggles the mind. Captain Ed crunches some numbers and finds compelling evidence of vote fraud in Wisconsin. (Michelle Malkin weighed in last night.) According to state records, 83,000 people executed a same-day registration for Milwaukee ... [Read More]

Tracked on January 18, 2005 9:36 AM

» Something Smelly in the Land of Cheese from RightPundit
Captain's Quarters has a link-filled post about the questionable results of Wisconsin's presidential election. John Kerry won Wisconsin by a mere 11,300 (a margin approximately one-tenth the size of George Bush's 100,000+ margin in Ohio). It now a... [Read More]

Tracked on January 18, 2005 9:54 AM

» Dairyland Defrauded from The Key Monk
But the REALITY of 10,000 unverifiable same-day votes in one city, Milwaukee, in a state that Bush "lost" by only 11,000+ votes strongly indicates something amiss. So do both the 69.7% voter turnout among Milwaukee County adults, compared to the 60% tu... [Read More]

Tracked on January 18, 2005 10:58 AM

» Ohio? What about Wisconsin? from Murdoc Online
The Silence Of The Cheese Captains Quarters notes some irregularities in Wisconsin. I don't think his point so much is "See? The Democrats cheated!" as it is "Why isn't this getting equal treatment?" He's got the numbers which show what... [Read More]

Tracked on January 18, 2005 11:43 AM

» Voter fraud.... from Media Lies Wisconsin? Captain Ed points out serious question marks surrounding the vote in Milwaukee County, not least an election day increase in voter registrations that seems quite anomalous. How did that happen? Well, in one county -- Milwauke... [Read More]

Tracked on January 18, 2005 2:06 PM

» Did the Democrats create their own voter problems? from Bit'sBlog
There's only a very few ways this goes down, people. Either the Democrats are total idiots and are the ones at fault for screwing this up... and screaming about it now is a rather strange omission of such... Or, else the voter problems are a red herr... [Read More]

Tracked on January 18, 2005 3:27 PM

» Voter Fraud in Wisconsin from The Political Teen
Via Captains Quarters To be honest, this is the first time I have heard about possible voter fraud in Wisconsin. This just goes to prove the point that Captain and Michelle has made. Where is the media and the Democrat's... [Read More]

Tracked on January 18, 2005 5:19 PM

» Wisconsin Has Some Explaining To Do from The Charlotte Capitalist
Were Wisconsin presidential election results false? Is the ongoing worry about Ohio simply a shield for what happened in Wisconsin? [Read More]

Tracked on January 20, 2005 5:20 AM

» The MSM President from Transterrestrial Musings
Commenter "Vulgorilla" asks a very simple question, about CBS, CNN and the MSM in general, over at Austin Bay's site:... [Read More]

Tracked on February 9, 2005 9:55 AM

Design & Skinning by:
m2 web studios

blog advertising


Proud Ex-Pat Member of the Bear Flag League!