Captain's Quarters Blog

« So Many Names, So Little Capacity For Thought | Main | Another Who Could Use Prayer »

January 31, 2005
Educational Death Penalty For Supporting Corporal Punishment?

CQ reader Dave Mendoza points me to an article that appeared in last week's Daily Orange, the campus newspaper of Syracuse University, regarding the expulsion of Scott McConnell from nearby LeMoyne College. McConnell, a graduate student in education, does not fit LeMoyne's atmosphere of political correctness. He believes in corporal punishment and rejects the focus on multiculturalism in the classroom:

While students are guaranteed the freedom of speech, LeMoyne College's recent actions against a student have raised questions of whether or not academic papers are the place to exercise this right.

LeMoyne College expelled Scott McConnell, a student from its Masters of Education program, for writing a paper in which he advocated the use of corporal punishment in schools, he said.

The paper, written for a class on classroom management, originally earned McConnell an A-. However, when he attempted to enroll in classes for the spring semester, he found he couldn't.

It wasn't just corporate punishment that got McConnell banished from LeMoyne, ironically a Catholic college that proclaims its commitment to "the Jesuit tradition" -- one that most Catholic-school kids would remember as not particularly shy about the paddle across the rear or rulers across the knuckles. (I went to public school, but in an era where both remedies remained available to teachers and administrators.) The Syracuse Post-Standard reported in an earlier story that McConnell's viewpoint on multiculturalism offended the enlightened souls at LeMoyne:

Dr. Cathy Leogrande, director of the Graduate Education Program, told McConnell in the letter that she had reviewed his grades and talked to his professors.

"I have grave concerns regarding the mismatch between your personal beliefs regarding teaching and learning and the Le Moyne College program goals," leading to the decision not to admit him, Leogrande wrote. ...

He said he's also been trying to find out what Leogrande meant by "mismatch." College administrators have told him, he said, that it stems from the four-page "Classroom Management Plan" he submitted Nov. 2 for his Planning, Assessing and Managing Inclusive Classrooms class.

In the opening paragraph of his essay, McConnell wrote: "I do not feel that multicultural education has a philosophical place or standing in an American classroom, especially one that I will teach. I also feel that corporal punishment has a place in the classroom and should be implemented when needed." He got an A for the course.

I do not know Scott McConnell, so I cannot peer into his soul to see why he objects to multicultural education. Perhaps McConnell was expressing latent racism. A better explanation, however, is that he sees the American classroom as a place for classic learning instead of social engineering, and that multiculturalism amounts to little more than political indoctrination, no matter how benign one considers it. A belief in corporal punishment also hardly qualifies one for public shunning. The notion may not enjoy massive popularity, but it isn't a fringe belief either.

Besides, the Jesuits have engaged in bitter irony in their treatment of McConnell. LeMoyne intends on protecting multiculturalism in the classroom -- by ensuring that everyone who enrolls at their college thinks exactly like they do. The administration shows its opposition to corporal punishment by giving any student espousing it the academic death penalty. The intellectual posturing and moral hypocrisy in these actions and positions truly dizzies the bystander.

Some still scoff when conservatives refer to the overwhelming liberal and leftist bias at universities and colleges in the US. This shows that far from striving to provide students the ability to debate and discuss all points of view, colleges and their administrations have developed a thought police of almost Orwellian proportions to defend their last bastion of Utopian thought. Academia provides no freedom of speech or conscience, and LeMoyne and the Jesuits have clearly communicated that in order to stay enrolled, students must never speak their minds. What a sad and sorry state for LeMoyne, its students, its alumni -- and for the students their graduates go on to teach in our classrooms.

Sphere It Digg! View blog reactions
Posted by Ed Morrissey at January 31, 2005 5:39 PM

Trackback Pings

TrackBack URL for this entry is

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Educational Death Penalty For Supporting Corporal Punishment?:

» Student Expelled for Thinking from Pete The Elder
If this story is accurate it reflects very poorly on the school and goes against the traditions of free academic inquiry. LeMoyne College apparently expelled a student named Scott McConnell for writing a paper in favor of corporal punishment for... [Read More]

Tracked on January 31, 2005 11:10 PM

» College Expels Education Student For Advocating.. from The Education Wonks
Scott McConnell, a student that attends LeMoyne College of Syracuse, New York, is charging that..... [Read More]

Tracked on February 1, 2005 2:29 AM

» College of Education Outrage! from Precinct 333
Scott McConnell, a student in the masters of Education program at LeMoyne College in Syracuse, New York, got an A- on his paper. He also was kicked out of school because of it. [Read More]

Tracked on February 1, 2005 5:22 AM

» A swing and a miss from Number 2 Pencil
Reader BBeeman sent a link my way about a pretty horrifying example of one university's opposition to free speech. It seems that LeMoyne College has rescinded their acceptance of a masters-level student in education for a paper that he wrote.... [Read More]

Tracked on February 1, 2005 6:19 AM

» 1st Amendment: No big deal? from Vote for Judges
Baloney. The schools and other institutions, notable among them Congress and the courts, have done too good a job of teaching the First Amendment. Disrespect for it, that is. [Read More]

Tracked on February 1, 2005 2:05 PM

» Academic Freedom of Speech, Continued from Moonage Political Webdream
Eugene Volokh relays a story:A graduate student at LeMoyne College has been expelled for writing a paper on his opinion that corporal punishment should be allowed in the classroom. Scott McConnell was working on his master’s degree in the science [Read More]

Tracked on February 7, 2005 8:47 AM

Design & Skinning by:
m2 web studios

blog advertising


Proud Ex-Pat Member of the Bear Flag League!