Captain's Quarters Blog

« E.J. Dionne: Stop The Insanity | Main | One More Look At Prague (Updates With Corroboration) »

August 12, 2005
Another Detail The 9/11 Commission Seems To Have Missed (Updated!)

Arrests corroborated by BBC and Reuters. See Update V.

Germany has long been known as one of the primary logistical areas for the 9/11 attacks. Mohammed Atta and several of the 9/11 hijackers spent considerable time in Hamburg especially during the recruitment and research effort in 1999 and 2000 before coming to the United States to begin the actual work of preparing the attacks. The 9/11 report contains 75 references to Germany, most of them involving Atta and his team; a search on Hamburg generates 90 hits. Three of the four pilots came from the Hamburg cell (page 242).

With all of these references to Germany and Hamburg, the 9/11 Commission oddly failed to include a published report from March 2001 in a Parisian Arabic newspaper, Al-Watan Al-Arabi, about the arrest of two suspected Iraqi spies -- based on a tip from the CIA (boldface mine):

Iraqi Spies Reportedly Arrested in Germany 16 March 2001

Al-Watan al-Arabi (Paris) reports that two Iraqis were arrested in Germany, charged with spying for Baghdad. The arrests came in the wake of reports that Iraq was reorganizing the external branches of its intelligence service and that it had drawn up a plan to strike at US interests around the world through a network of alliances with extremist fundamentalist parties.

The most serious report contained information that Iraq and Osama bin Ladin were working together. German authorities were surprised by the arrest of the two Iraqi agents and the discovery of Iraqi intelligence activities in several German cities. German authorities, acting on CIA recommendations, had been focused on monitoring the activities of Islamic groups linked to bin Ladin. They discovered the two Iraqi agents by chance and uncovered what they considered to be serious indications of cooperation between Iraq and bin Ladin. The matter was considered so important that a special team of CIA and FBI agents was sent to Germany to interrogate the two Iraqi spies.

Not one word of this gets addressed in the final Commission report, as far as I can tell. The report contains thirty-one references to arrests, most of them for Khalid Sheikh Mohammed and Zacarias Moussaoui, but none of them mention any German arrests of Iraqi spies in Germany for March 2001. It isn't as if the 9/11 Commission considered Al-Watan al-Arabi an unreliable source, either; they used it as a reference for an editorial by Saudi Prince Bandar.

The CIA apparently knew something about this; why didn't it come out during the hearings? This looks like a very strange coincidence, that the Germans found such an extensive Iraqi espionage ring within their borders at the same time that al-Qaeda planned its largest and most complicated attack on Western interests ever. That attack required extraordinary coordination and planning, with a large amount of resourcing. The attacks before and since have all been suicide or hit-and-run affairs, on a much smaller scale and with much more modest ambitions.

This information was published contemporaneously in March 2001 and was in the public domain. If anyone brought it to the Commission's attention, no evidence of it exists in the report. Presumably, such public information would have been addressed in the report even if it turned out to be mistaken had anyone bothered to look at it -- or if the Commission could explain it away in favor of their "no operational connection" analysis between Iraq and 9/11.

In March 2001, the CIA suspected that the Iraqis had allied themselves with Islamist extremists to carry out attacks on American interests, and as a result the Germans discovered exactly that -- right where the planning for 9/11 took place. Did this information get the Able Danger treatment as well? (h/t: CQ reader Tom M.)

Addendum: It's worth noting that syndicated columnist Amir Taheri considered Al-Watan Al-Arabi to be a pro-Saddam weekly.

UPDATE: These arrests don't appear to have made it into Stephen Hayes' book The Connection, either.

UPDATE II: A commenter asks me if I believe that Saddam had an active role in 9/11. Up to this week, I've been fairly satisfied with the "no proven operational connection" determination made by the 9/11 Commission regarding the attacks -- though reading Hayes' book shows us plenty of other efforts by Saddam to reach out to radical Islamists. With an apparent attempt to suppress certain kinds of evidence now coming to light with the Able Danger revelations, though, the entire report and its conclusions no longer hold much credibility. It appears that the Commission's efforts aimed at supporting a preconceived narrative, and that may be the best that can be said of it.

Remembering what analysts said about the attack in the days following 9/11, all of them seem surprised at the sophistication and coordination of the operation. Al-Qaeda had never attempted a mission on that scale before, and it hasn't since then, either. I recall plenty of experts talking for weeks afterward how that kind of well-timed and effective attack required strong logistical support, training, and funding. Perhaps AQ managed to pull that all together once; maybe not. I think we need to take another look at 9/11, starting completely fresh. What we have has massive holes in it, as we have all discovered in the last 72 hours or so.

UPDATE III: Pierre at Pink Flamingo has had this information on his site for almost three years. (Sorry, Pierre, it didn't pop up on Google.)

UPDATE IV: I thought most people knew about Ramzi Yousef and the Iraqi passport. Here's one narrative from

The first major explosion Ramzi Yousef added to his resume was significant in a number of ways -- the World Trade Center.

In late 1992, Yousef entered the country with a fake Iraqi passport and asked for asylum. His traveling companion was arrested immediately when a search of his luggage revealed bomb-making manuals. Because the INS holding cells were overcrowded, Yousef was released with instructions to come back a month later for a hearing.

More from Laurie Mylroie:

Several Iraqis hovered around the fringe of the plot. One, Abdul Rahman Yasin, is the sole remaining indicted fugitive. Born in the United States while his father was a graduate student here, Yasin was able to obtain a U.S. passport in June 1992. Yasin arrived in New York from Baghdad in September 1992. He returned there shortly after the Trade Center bombing, transiting through Jordan, where he stopped at the Iraqi embassy and quickly (within 24 hours) received a visa for his U.S. passport. Much later, U.S. authorities found documents in Iraq that showed Yasin was rewarded with a house and monthly stipend. Ramzi Yousef was a second key figure in that attack. Like Yasin, Yousef arrived in New York in early September 1992. At Kennedy Airport, Yousef presented an Iraqi passport, with stamps showing that his trip began in Baghdad. The immigration inspector who processed him testified that Yousef's passport "appeared to be valid and unaltered."

And so on; here's the Google search that brings up plenty of references.

UPDATE V: These arrests have been corroborated by contemporaneous reports from the BBC and Reuters, quoted by Newsmax here.

Sphere It Digg! View blog reactions
Posted by Ed Morrissey at August 12, 2005 12:26 PM

Trackback Pings

TrackBack URL for this entry is

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Another Detail The 9/11 Commission Seems To Have Missed (Updated!):

» Able Danger, Iraq Update VII from The Strata-Sphere
Massive kudos to Ed Morrissey for an excellent find of something absolutely critical to the 9-11 commission’s now bogus conclusions. I was a bit doubtful when the good Captain jumped from the Able Danger story to Iraqi connections to Atta (look... [Read More]

Tracked on August 12, 2005 1:13 PM

» Sorcerer of The Wonkavator from NIF
Today's dose of NIF - News, Interesting & Funny ... Thank.God.Its.Friday, seriously! [Read More]

Tracked on August 12, 2005 1:57 PM

» If the US Government had checked my page they woul from The Pink Flamingo Bar Grill
On my Connections between Al Queda and Saddam page, that has been up for nearly 3 years, I have had that arrest listed [Read More]

Tracked on August 12, 2005 2:41 PM

» DUELING BLOGSWARMS from Right Wing Nut House
It’s a fascinating day here in blogland. We have dueling blogswarms between the left and right, each trying to push a story into prominence in the mainstream media. On the left, there’s the Cindy Sheehan story and what’s rapidly be... [Read More]

Tracked on August 12, 2005 4:56 PM

» No, Iraq Had Nothing to do with 9/11 from The Jawa Report
Is the 9/11 Report flawed? Yes. But that does not mean there was a conspiracy to keep information out of the report. It is the inherent nature of government reports, all government reports, to be flawed. If you don't want... [Read More]

Tracked on August 12, 2005 5:13 PM

» There were no operational ties... from As I Please

Tracked on August 12, 2005 6:06 PM

» Rusty logic from ReidBlog
Every so often, a member of the vast right wing conspiracy makes perfect sense. [Read More]

Tracked on August 12, 2005 9:21 PM

» Was 9/11 an Iraqi plot hatched in Baghdad? from Media Lies
Seems ridiculous? Totally contrary to logic? Maybe not. Captain Ed, inspired by the Able Danger revelations, has been digging for information about Iraqi ties to... [Read More]

Tracked on August 12, 2005 10:30 PM

» Blogstorm Warning from Everyman
You need to read the following - updated as of last night, not as of this morning, so there may be more that should be added to the list (and no doubt are) - about the rapidly developing story of the 9/11 Commission's failure (refusal?) to deal with th... [Read More]

Tracked on August 13, 2005 8:36 AM

» Submitted for Your Approval from Watcher of Weasels
First off...  any spambots reading this should immediately go here, here, here,  and here.  Die spambots, die!  And now...  here are all the links submitted by members of the Watcher's Council for this week's vote. Council link... [Read More]

Tracked on August 17, 2005 2:43 AM

» Iraq Connected to 9-11 from The Strata-Sphere
I think Americans can rightfully feel like they have been lied to or duped by politicians in Washington trying to cover for the Clinton Administration. One thing the Able Danger issue did cause was a re-examination of events that could be gleaned by ... [Read More]

Tracked on August 29, 2005 8:24 AM

» More on the Iraq-al Qaeda Connection from The Unalienable Right
Stephen F. Hayes has written another good article - See No Evil, Hear No Evil - for The Weekly Standard about the evidence of a connection between al Qaeda and Iraq. AHMED HIKMAT SHAKIR IS A shadowy figure who provided logistical assistance to one, ... [Read More]

Tracked on August 30, 2005 2:30 PM

» The Justifications for the Invasion of Iraq from ProCynic
One thing which my recent trip to California has highlighted for me is the misinformation and misunderstanding that is present on our West Coast about the war in Iraq. Much of this is to be expected when your main news organ is the Los Angeles Times,... [Read More]

Tracked on November 13, 2005 10:18 PM

Design & Skinning by:
m2 web studios

blog advertising


Proud Ex-Pat Member of the Bear Flag League!