Captain's Quarters Blog

« Able Danger: Third Source Steps Up, Gives Even More Details | Main | Able Danger: Mixed Wires And Chinese Fried Rice »

August 26, 2005
Ruffini Calls Me Out

Patrick Ruffini has wrapped up his highly successful and intriguing presidential straw poll, designed to not only determine the front-running Republicans in the blogosphere but to break down the demographics in several categories. Readers can see the results at this post, and use the drop-down boxes to see the breakdowns. Patrick even compares the results based on blogger endorsements, noting that I had withheld mine and asking me for it now.

The win for Rudy Giuliani surprised me, given the less-than-centrist nature of the blogosphere. I love Rudy; he showed the world in the hours, days, and weeks after 9/11 that Americans would not allow themselves to be defeated. His grit, determination, and courage inspired all of us. He's great on the stump, too, one of the best speakers we have in politics on either side. But that's the problem with Rudy -- he's on either side in too many categories. For a party already grumbling about the lack of conservatism from the current GOP president, the pro-choice, pro-gay rights, Rockefeller-Republican Giuliani doesn't make much sense. He could win handily in the general election, but he'd never get there.

In his way, Giuliani would be the Joe Lieberman of the GOP: the guy who could have won if his party had nominated him. The key is that the GOP have other great candidates on the bench.

CQ readers and the overall vote selected my early choice for the nomination as the #2 man. George Allen has sterling conservative credentials, and has served as both a Senator and a Governor, giving him a broad resume. He also has good rapport with an audience and a bit more amiability than Giuliani, who can come across as cold and angry at times. Allen also has good name recognition. Allen makes the best case for the top slot, including his status as a Southerner. Mike Huckabee would also be a good selection, although his name recognition doesn't come close to Allen's.

I wasn't disappointed at all in John McCain's showing. At one time, the Arizona "maverick" might have captured the imagination of the GOP base, but not after his series of defections. His two accomplishments, the BCRA and the Memorandum that stopped the filibuster fight, did not endear him at all to the base -- and this poll reflects that very well.

Be sure to check out all of Patrick's fine work. I especially liked the "fantasy" candidates idea, and the numbers there prove especially intriguing.

Sphere It Digg! View blog reactions
Posted by Ed Morrissey at August 26, 2005 9:48 PM

Trackback Pings

TrackBack URL for this entry is

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Ruffini Calls Me Out:

» Other Bloggers On Mike Huckabee from Mike Huckabee President 2008
Captain Ed at Captain's Quarters says of 2008 "Allen makes the best case for the top slot, including his status as a Southerner. Mike Huckabee would also be a good selection, although his name recognition doesn't come close to Allen's." We're working... [Read More]

Tracked on August 27, 2005 8:15 AM

» The Friday Grab-Bag: A Saturday Edition from Eternity Road
(Well, why not? If "60 Minutes" can do it...!) Your Curmudgeon isn't from one of the hairier segments of the human race. (As if you couldn't tell from the photo.) All the same, he and the C.S.O. have long preferred less body hair to... [Read More]

Tracked on August 27, 2005 8:32 AM

Design & Skinning by:
m2 web studios

blog advertising


Proud Ex-Pat Member of the Bear Flag League!