For long-term disasters like famines, one can usually find a political problem that keeps food and medicine from the people who need it, rather than a purely environmental issue. This has been true of African catastrophes like Ethiopa and Somalia, where the means for food production have fallen victim to dictatorships that use food as a weapon against their enemies. It turns out that the same dynamic can be found in shorter-term disasters -- like tsunamis, for instance. The massive aid sent to Aceh in the aftermath of the killer tidal waves of two years ago has not funded relief, but instead enabled a new shari'a police that have subjugated the women of Aceh:

WHEN people around the world sent millions of pounds to help the stricken Indonesian province of Aceh after the Boxing Day tsunami of 2004, few could have imagined that their money would end up subsidising the lashing of women in public.

But militant Islamists have since imposed sharia law in Aceh and have cornered Indonesian government funds to organise a moral vigilante force that harasses women and stages frequent displays of humiliation and state-sanctioned violence.

International aid workers and Indonesian women’s organisations are now expressing dismay that the flow of foreign cash for reconstruction has allowed the government to spend scarce money on a new bureaucracy and religious police to enforce puritan laws, such as the compulsory wearing of headscarves. ...

In one town, Lhokseumawe, the authorities are even planning to impose a curfew on women — a move that social workers warn will force tsunami widows to quit night-time jobs as food sellers or waitresses and could drive them into prostitution.

The entire spectacle has more than a whiff of repressed sexuality about it. Women accused of moral crimes get hauled in front of a crowd of jeering men, who work themselves into a state of hysteria while the charges are read. Then the women get caned as many as ten times to the exultation of the men watching the punishment. It sounds like a strange outlet for a severely repressed society, especially as the morality squad has conducted more than 140 times now.

The problem with foreign aid for disaster sites is the prevailing political structure of the country or area. When the government is corrupt, the aid will not go to its intended recipients but instead to support the corrupt government. Massive amounts of cash only serve to allow these regimes to keep and extend their grip on power. In this case, some could be forgiven for forgetting the lesson, given the random and acute nature of the disaster, but it shows that even in these circumstances aid will get diverted to purposes other than those intended.

Western nations need to develop new methods of aid delivery. We cannot simply refuse to help when people starve to death or when tsunamis strike, but we also cannot fund the imposition of shari'a and other kinds of oppression. We need to insist on controlling the delivery channels for aid to ensure that it reaches the real victims. When we have successfully done so, we have seen the benefits of our generosity reflected in the improved lives of the downtrodden. When we do not, we become accessories to the violence and abuse that the powerless receive.

Trackback Pings

TrackBack URL for this entry is

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference How Foreign Aid Hurts Rather Than Helps:

» Web Reconnaissance for 12/18/2006 from The Thunder Run
A short recon of what’s out there that might draw your attention. [Read More]

Tracked on December 18, 2006 10:10 AM

» Tsunami donations paying for shari’a, abuse of women in Indonesia from Bill's Bites
How Foreign Aid Hurts Rather Than HelpsEd Morrissey For long-term disasters like famines, one can usually find a political problem that keeps food and medicine from the people who need it, rather than a purely environmental issue. This has been [Read More]

Tracked on December 18, 2006 10:47 AM

» Tsunami survivors given the lash from Don Singleton
It reminds me when the taliban were using internationally built soccer stadiums for public executions, and when the international community objected, they said they would be happy to have the international community pay to build them other facilities... [Read More]

Tracked on December 18, 2006 10:48 AM

» Like I Didn’t See This Coming - Just Another Cause for Concern from Webloggin
My Christmas wish for this year is that America wakes up and cuts their water off. I am not going to be a willing participant to the lack of commonsense that keeps the terrorists afloat and I urge my fellow countrymen to do the same. ... [Read More]

Tracked on December 18, 2006 12:43 PM

» Bang for your aid buck from SCSU Scholars
Captain Ed writes a couple of articles yesterday and today on the question of aid for developing countries. First, writing about tsunami aid in Aceh, Indonesia, he notes: The problem with foreign aid for disaster sites is the prevailing politica ..... [Read More]

Tracked on December 19, 2006 11:37 AM