Captain's Quarters Blog

« Russia Uses Energy To Spread Tentacles | Main | In Mogadishu, It's Miller Time »

January 3, 2007
Ban Puts Saddam Death Penalty In Perspective

This change promises a return to common sense at Turtle Bay, and will likely drive Kofi Annan fans up the nearest wall. Newly-inducted UN Secretary-General Ban Ki Moon defended Iraq's imposition of the death penalty as a question of sovereignty and reminded protestors around the world about the nature of the man whose death they lament:

U.N. Secretary General Ban Ki Moon said Tuesday that Iraq and other countries have the right to impose the death penalty, adding that the world should never forget Saddam Hussein's "heinous crimes."

Ban's first public reaction to Hussein's execution signaled a sharp break from his predecessor, Kofi Annan, an ardent death-penalty critic who opposed U.N. participation in the Iraqi war crimes tribunal that sentenced Hussein to die. Human rights advocates expressed concern that Ban's comments lend credibility to what they see as a flawed trial of the former Iraqi leader, and complained that he could set back efforts to abolish the death penalty.

The remarks suggest that the former South Korean foreign minister, who began a five- year term on Monday, would defer to the United Nations' 192 member states on some of the day's most controversial and unsettled issues. Nearly 70 countries, including the United States and South Korea, retain the death penalty.

"Saddam Hussein was responsible for committing heinous crimes and unspeakable atrocities against the Iraqi people," Ban said in his first news conference as secretary general. "The issue of capital punishment is for each and every member state to decide."

I'm no fan of the death penalty, but I am a proponent of national sovereignty over governance through the UN. This statement from Ban suggests that he has the same outlook, and it should serve as a reversal of thought among Turtle Bay power elites. For too long, the UN bureaucracy and leadership have taken for granted the notion that the UN represents some sort of supergovernment rather than a diplomatic venue, and Annan was among the worst at using his position to meddle in sovereign affairs of member states.

Iraq has a representative government elected by its people. If they want to abolish the death penalty, then they will elect representatives who will do so. Right now it appears to be popular among Iraqis, but that may well change after Saddam's execution. I don't think anyone believes it was handled properly, and the sectarian triumphalism apparent at the execution may well give some momentum to President Talabani's opposition to capital punishment in Iraq.

Annan would have taken the opportunity to scold the Iraqis and to tell them how to run their country. Ban quite appropriately has decided that internal Iraqi political decisions, freely chosen by their elected representatives, has no bearing on the UN or its mission. If we're lucky, this will presage a period of modesty from the United Nations that, given its own track record of corruption and incompetence, is long overdue.

UPDATE: Corrected use of surname, which is Ban and not Moon. Thanks to Jim L for the note.

Sphere It Digg! View blog reactions
Posted by Ed Morrissey at January 3, 2007 4:54 AM

Trackback Pings

TrackBack URL for this entry is

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Ban Puts Saddam Death Penalty In Perspective:

» from Bill's Bites
Oh, Give Me A Break John Hinderaker CNN Europe reports that Italians are shocked--shocked!--by the cell phone video of Saddam Hussein's execution, and are calling for a United Nations ban on all capital punishment:Italy will campaign at the United Nations [Read More]

Tracked on January 3, 2007 5:53 AM

» U.N.’s Ban Defend’s Saddam’s Execution from The American Mind
New U.N. Secretary General Ban Ki Moon is sure to eventually tick off most American conservatives. It is the U.N., that bastion of bureaucratic, paper-shuffling, anti-Americanism that poses as a world diplomatic body. If his first day on the job is any... [Read More]

Tracked on January 3, 2007 7:34 AM

» New U.N. Chief Defends Death Penalty for Hussein from Stop The ACLU
We have written before on how the new U.N. Secretary General, Ban Ki Moon, may be the best thing to ever happen for the U.N.  Yes, I am still reluctant to lavish praise, after all it is the U.N., but so far the new top dog at the U.N. is sounding lik... [Read More]

Tracked on January 3, 2007 9:22 AM

» Good First Week on the Job: Ban Ki-moon from Y.A.C.R.W.B
The more I hear about Ban Ki-moon - the new Secretary General of the UN, the more I like. While I am under no illusion that he can change the large, inept organization into a power for good, he at least seems to be far and away better connected to real... [Read More]

Tracked on January 3, 2007 10:46 AM


Design & Skinning by:
m2 web studios

blog advertising


Proud Ex-Pat Member of the Bear Flag League!