February 17, 2007

Washington Post Spanks Murtha

The unbelievable cynicism of John Murtha's "slow bleed" plan to end the war in Iraq has not gone unnoticed by the Washington Post. The editorial board excoriates Murtha in no uncertain terms not just for his plan to elevate the Democrats on the backs of the troops in Iraq, but also for his ignorance on Iraq (via Instapundit):

Mr. Murtha has a different idea. He would stop the surge by crudely hamstringing the ability of military commanders to deploy troops. In an interview carried Thursday by the Web site MoveCongress.org, Mr. Murtha said he would attach language to a war funding bill that would prohibit the redeployment of units that have been at home for less than a year, stop the extension of tours beyond 12 months, and prohibit units from shipping out if they do not train with all of their equipment. His aim, he made clear, is not to improve readiness but to "stop the surge." So why not straightforwardly strip the money out of the appropriations bill -- an action Congress is clearly empowered to take -- rather than try to micromanage the Army in a way that may be unconstitutional? Because, Mr. Murtha said, it will deflect accusations that he is trying to do what he is trying to do. "What we are saying will be very hard to find fault with," he said.

Mr. Murtha's cynicism is matched by an alarming ignorance about conditions in Iraq. He continues to insist that Iraq "would be more stable with us out of there," in spite of the consensus of U.S. intelligence agencies that early withdrawal would produce "massive civilian casualties." He says he wants to force the administration to "bulldoze" the Abu Ghraib prison, even though it was emptied of prisoners and turned over to the Iraqi government last year. He wants to "get our troops out of the Green Zone" because "they are living in Saddam Hussein's palace"; could he be unaware that the zone's primary occupants are the Iraqi government and the U.S. Embassy?

It would be nice to believe that Mr. Murtha does not represent the mainstream of the Democratic Party or the thinking of its leadership. Yet when asked about Mr. Murtha's remarks Thursday, House Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.) offered her support. Does Ms. Pelosi really believe that the debate she orchestrated this week was not "the real vote"? If the answer is yes, she is maneuvering her party in a way that can only do it harm.

Has John Murtha ever been anything more than incoherent on Iraq? He talks loudly but says next to nothing other than reiterate the need to declare defeat and bug out of Iraq. He can't even get his facts straight despite having spent the better part of two years making himself the leading Democratic voice on the war. Even the Washington Post can't help but notice that this Emperor has no clothes.

Despite this, Pelosi insists on following his leadership on Iraq policy. The Democrats have made the case yet again why they cannot be trusted with national security. They use bad information, faulty logic, and underhanded tactics to exploit it for partisan political purposes. John Murtha represents everything that is wrong with the Democrats on this debate. They are ill-informed and incoherent, unable to formulate a plan for victory but willing to sabotage American efforts anyway.

It's going to be a long two years.


TrackBack URL for this entry:

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Washington Post Spanks Murtha:

I got an earful from some of my friends on the left for taking Representative John Murtha and the Democrats to task for their moral cowardice in not directly trying to defund the war but rather slink in the shadows and attempt to sabotage deployments ... [Read More]

» New Dhimm Strategy: Betray The Troops -- Update 4 from Bill's Bites
Murtha: U.S. Troops “Have Everything They Need,” live in palace(s) Ian Schwartz CNS:He did not elaborate but went on to talk about services enjoyed by U.S. troops in Iraq but denied to many Iraqis. “Let’s take, for instance, Saddam Hussein’s [Read More]

» Commentary on the House Resolution to Lose the Iraq War from GINA COBB
There's so much good commentary out there on the House resolution to lose the Iraq war that I'll just point you to it and get out of the way. But first, a word puzzle. How do Democrats in Congress show their support for the troops? [Read More]

» Murtha:Troops "Have Everything they need...Live in from The Discerning Texan
This guy has really gone Cindy Sheehan-postal. My God, am I supposed to believe that this traitor was a United States Marine? That is sort of analogous to finding out that Benjamin Netanyahu was in the Hitler Youth; it simply boggles the mind. [Read More]

» John Murtha -- Angry Little Man from Scottish Right
Well, he's at it again. Ranting Democratic Congressman John Murtha is having a bill drafted with the intent of undercutting President Bush's planned troop surge in Iraq. Rather than expressly preventing the surge by cutting off funding, the bill woul... [Read More]

» John Murtha, "Alarming ignorance" from Degree of Madness
The Washington Post editorial board weighs in on Rep. John Murtha's (D-PA) slow bleed strategy to end the war in Iraq. Mr. Murtha's cynicism is matched by an alarming ignorance about conditions in Iraq. He continues to insist that Iraq [Read More]

» The Knucklehead of the Day award from The Florida Masochist
Today's winner is Congressman John Murtha. [Read More]

» Sorta Blogless Sunday Pinup from Pirate's Cove
And a Happy Sunday to all! This pinup is by Edward Runci, with an addition. It is in honor of today being National Crab Stuffed Flounder day. Hey, don't look at me, I didn't make it up. It is also in honor of the troops, of which 182 Repr... [Read More]