February 16, 2008

The Coming Obama 'Theocracy'

People mocked Mike Huckabee and Mitt Romney for their religious backgrounds often during the presidential campaigns, but at least they never claimed to be on a mission to save the souls of Americans through government action. Oh, people accused them of wanting to do so -- to impose Southern Baptist or Mormon theology on an America that wants relentless secularism, but in point of fact both men gave stirring speeches on how their faith informs them personally but not their governance.

One campaign really has explicitly claimed to be on such a mission, however. Michelle Obama gave a speech at UCLA earlier this month in which she told supporters that her husband was the only man who could fix American souls -- if we elect him President first. Here's the transcript:

In 2008, we are still a nation that is too divided. We live in isolation, and because of that isolation, we fear one another. We don't know our neighbors, we don't talk, we believe our pain is our own. We don't realize that the struggles and challenges of all of us are the same. We are too isolated. And we are still a nation that is still too cynical. We look at it as "them" and "they" as opposed to "us". We don't engage because we are still too cynical. ...

Americans are not in debt because they live frivolously but because someone got sick. Even with insurance, the deductibles and the premiums are so high that people are still putting medications and treatments on credit cards. And they can't get out from under. I could go on and on, but this is how we're living, people, in 2008.

And things have gotten progressively worse throughout my lifetime, through Democratic and Republican administrations, it hasn't gotten better for regular folks. ....

We have lost the understanding that in a democracy, we have a mutual obligation to one another -- that we cannot measure the greatness of our society by the strongest and richest of us, but we have to measure our greatness by the least of these. That we have to compromise and sacrifice for one another in order to get things done. That is why I am here, because Barack Obama is the only person in this who understands that. That before we can work on the problems, we have to fix our souls. Our souls are broken in this nation.

It's hard to know where to start in with this speech. First, what evidence does Mrs. Obama have that the largest part of credit card debt goes to health care? Second, if she has seen the standard of living get progressively worse during her lifetime, she needs new glasses. The living standard of even those classified as poor now have per-person expenditures of the American middle-class of the early 1970s, according to the Census Bureau. Eighty percent of the poor live in air-conditioned housing, 43% of them own their own homes, and the average poor American has as much living space than the average individual living in Paris, London, Vienna, and Athens. Only 3% don't own a color TV.

But it's the notion that only Barack Obama can save our souls that is the most offensive part of the speech, by far. Government doesn't exist to save souls; it exists to ensure domestic tranquility and provide for the common defense. If I feel my soul needs saving, the very last place I'd look (in the US) for a savior would be Washington DC or Capitol Hill. I'll trust God and Jesus Christ with my soul, and I'm not going to mistake Barack Obama for either one.

This, though, is the religion of statism distilled to its essence. Only a government can rescue people from the consequences of their own decisions. Only government programs can provide for your every need, and only government can use your money wisely enough to ensure that your needs get covered. Individuals cannot possibly manage to help their neighbors through their churches or community organizations, let alone encourage people to do for themselves.

And all you need to enter the statist Utopia is to sell your soul. So that it can be fixed.

No, thank you.

UPDATE: Ron at Liberal Values implies that I'm a hypocrite. Ron's a good guy, but he's wrong. People rely on their values to formulate policy, and religious values are just as legitimate as others for that purpose. People who claim to know the status of my soul and promise that they can fix it through government intervention -- on either side of the aisle -- explicitly have crossed a line, not to mention exhibited arrogance in diagnosing the status of my soul.

Michelle Malkin responds:

When Republicans talk about broken souls in the context of civil society, the nutroots start screaming about the obliteration of the church-state line.

When the Obama campaign uses the same rhetoric to get him elected to the White House, everyone swoons.

I'd rather both just stick to policy, and let me worry about the status of my soul.


TrackBack URL for this entry:

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference The Coming Obama 'Theocracy':

» Obama Akbar! from The Sundries Shack
Barak Obama is the one true God and Michelle Obama is his prophet. I wonder how the ninnies who squeal about “Christianists” and the “American Taliban” will twist their brains to justify this outright call for a statist Theocr... [Read More]

» Michelle Obama: Barack is the only man who can “heal” this nation and “fix our souls” from Sister Toldjah
I just got done listening to the most disturbing speech of this campaign season, and it wasn’t given by any of the candidates, but by the wife of the Dem frontrunner for the nomination: Michelle Obama. It was given two weeks ago at UCLA. Captai... [Read More]

» Republican Bloggers Look In Wrong Direction When Warning of Theocracy from Liberal Values
The hypocrisy of Republicans is just amazing. Most of the time they complain about the evils of secular liberals. Therefore you would think they would be happy if a Democrat speaks of religion. Ed Morrissey claims that a theocracy is coming under Obama... [Read More]

» Barack Obama: Making things grow from sisu
MoveOn shows what Americans can achieve when we come together in a grass-roots movement for change, declared Barack Obama -- apparently not recognizing crabgrass for the weed it is (above, invading our terrace last summer) -- in a statement issued [Read More]

» Michelle Obama's Got Soul from Cobb
But don't let her get yours. Michelle Obama recently spoke to students at UCLA. Hugh Hewitt's radio show gave some poleaxing polemics on some of her exclamation points. But it didn't take a media assassin to hear that she was [Read More]

» "We Have To Fix Our Souls" from Ed Driscoll.com
This past September, I pondered if Michelle Obama was the next Teresa Heinz, whose soundbites would cause much damage control for her husband's presidential campaign. To her credit though, Teresa never said, "we have to fix our souls. Our souls... [Read More]

» Mixing Religion and Politics from Blatant Reality
You hear it all the time about how conservative candidates shouldn’t be mixing politics and religion. This presidential race has definitely seen its fair share of news articles questioning whether conservative presidential candidates Mike Huckabe... [Read More]

» A Mirror Of Desire from Blue Crab Boulevard
Tom Maguire looks at Barack Obama's appeal. He contends that it is the projection of people's internal desires onto the surface of a mirror. That is the problem for Hillary Clinton. Allow me to expand on my notion that Obama is the M... [Read More]

» Obama: Swoons, signs and wonders. Is he the Saviour of America? from Leaning Straight Up
Admittedly this is one of those stories that I want to file under "What the Hell!" or "stranger than fiction". But then again, nothing - or at least very little - in American Politics it really so unbelievable or implausible as to be tot... [Read More]

» Obama Messiah from Public Secrets: from the files of the Irishspy
The Obama campaign has taken on the quality almost of a religious revival, with the Prophet Barack here to save our souls. It even has women fainting during his speeches. (Are we sure they're not collapsing from the vacuum of [Read More]

Barack Obama has been successful in the Democratic primaries and caucuses largely because he doesn’t seem as threatening as Hillary Clinton. Even for Democrats, Hillary is a little scary. I mean, we’re talking about someone who sees polit... [Read More]

When I read the following over at Captain’s Quarters, I think–I’m not sure, mind you–but I think I came the closest I ever came to pissing myself in laughter without actually doing it.    Mind you, the Extra Crispy Right Wing... [Read More]

» The Obama Messiah Phenomenon also Known as Obamessiah from Blue Star Chronicles
Photo courtesy of the Obamamessiah website I heard some Barack Obama campaign people today making a point of pointing out that Obama is making a point of speaking to the issues in his latest speeches. This is in reaction to the allegations from the Cl... [Read More]

» The Cult of Obama from Hoystory
I’ve got Jewel’s “Who will save your soul?” song stuck in my head after listening to this speech by Michelle Obama, wife of Democratic presidential hopeful Barack, from a campaign rally a couple weeks back at UCLA. Captain Ed ha... [Read More]

» Smelling Salts from Ironic Surrealism II
Of late there have been numerous reports regarding members of Obama’s flock actually ‘fainting’ in his presence. Yes that is what I said folks. Fainting! Good God, next thing you’ll know is there will be official Obama ’sm... [Read More]

» Michelle Obama: "For the first time in my adult lifetime, I am really proud of my country" from Anchor Rising
Michelle Obama just said these words: ...What we have learned over this year is that hope is making a comeback. It is making a comeback. And let me tell you something -- for the first time in my adult lifetime,... [Read More]

Please note that unverified Disqus users will have comments held in moderation. Please visit Disqus to register and verify your account. Comments from verified users will appear immediately.