Captain's Quarters Blog

« CNN/Gallup: Bush Up By Eight In Florida | Main | Kerry Campaign Keeps Running With Discredited Story »

October 25, 2004
NY Times Keeps Running With Discredited Story

Despite the NBC News report that told America that its own reporters verified the HMX and RDX had been removed from the Al-Qaqaa bunker in Iraq before American soldiers ever got there, the New York Times continues to push its discredited "gotcha" on its front page:

The White House sought on Monday to explain the disappearance of 380 tons of high explosives in Iraq that American forces were supposed to secure, as Senator John Kerry seized on the missing cache as "one of the great blunders of Iraq" and said President Bush's "incredible incompetence" had put American troops at risk. ...

Yet even as Mr. Bush pressed his case, his aides tried to explain why American forces had ignored a series of warnings from the International Atomic Energy Agency about the vulnerability of the huge stockpile of high explosives, which was first reported on Monday by CBS and The New York Times.

In several sessions with reporters, the White House spokesman, Scott McClellan, alternately insisted that Mr. Bush "wants to make sure that we get to the bottom of this" and tried to distance the president from knowledge of the issue, saying Mr. Bush was informed of the disappearance only within the last 10 days. White House officials said they could not explain why warnings from the International Atomic Energy Agency in May 2003 about the vulnerability of the stockpile to looting never resulted in action. At one point, Mr. McClellan pointed out that "there were a number of priorities at the end of Operation Iraqi Freedom."

Times write David Sanger never bothers to mention the fact that NBC's report earlier tonight essentially negated the entire thrust of their argument (also at Drudge):

NBC News: Miklaszewski: April 10, 2003, only three weeks into the war, NBC News was embedded with troops from the Army's 101st Airborne as they temporarily take over the Al Qakaa weapons installation south of Baghdad. But these troops never found the nearly 380 tons of some of the most powerful conventional explosives, called HMX and RDX, which is now missing. The U.S. troops did find large stockpiles of more conventional weapons, but no HMX or RDX, so powerful less than a pound brought down Pan Am 103 in 1988, and can be used to trigger a nuclear weapon. In a letter this month, the Iraqi interim government told the International Atomic Energy Agency the high explosives were lost to theft and looting due to lack of security. Critics claim there were simply not enough U.S. troops to guard hundreds of weapons stockpiles, weapons now being used by insurgents and terrorists to wage a guerrilla war in Iraq. (NBCs Nightly News, 10/25/04)

As I posted earlier, this confirms that the materials had already been moved or looted from the site before American troops arrived at Al-Qaqaa. After finding the IAEA seals already broken and no high-priority materiel on site, the Americans moved on to more pressing problems -- like combat and securing lines of communication.

The bigger question we should ask is why the Times feels the need to push this story so hard. It's not exactly like Rathergate in that no fraudulent documents have been used to rationalize the story, but it feels like the Times may be trying very hard to find anything that will embarass the President in the final week of campaigning. In this case, the Times rushed a story to its pages without doing any proper research on the underlying facts, and wound up getting smacked down by NBC.

It's not the first time the paper has gone on a political crusade, although Pinch Sulzberger assured us that the dark days of Howell Raines were long gone, along with obsessions like the Augusta Masters. It appears that managing editor Jill Abramson has indulged another obsession -- defeating George Bush. This agenda-driven journalism threatens to deflate the Paper of Record's reputation just as surely as Rathergate did CBS, fake documents or no.

The Times needs to place a moratorium on further articles on missing weapons until it does proper research, and it owes its readers and the Americans in Iraq working munitions demolitions a big apology.

UPDATE: Lori from Polipundit wants your help in naming the scandal.

Sphere It Digg! View blog reactions
Posted by Ed Morrissey at October 25, 2004 10:54 PM

Trackback Pings

TrackBack URL for this entry is

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference NY Times Keeps Running With Discredited Story:

» NBC News to John Kerry and the NYT: "Oh no you did-ent!" from protein wisdom
From Jim Geraghty, NRO's "Kerry Spot":Jim Miklaszewski of NBC News pretty much dismantled the New York Times attack on behalf of Kerry today. NBC News: Miklaszewski: “April 10, 2003, only three weeks into the war, NBC News was embedded... [Read More]

Tracked on October 25, 2004 11:25 PM

» Old Media's "al Qaqaa Cacaphony" turns out to be ALL KAKA and PHONY from The Astute Blogger
[Read More]

Tracked on October 25, 2004 11:47 PM

» Old Media's al Qaqaa Cacaphony turns out to be "ALL KAKA" and PHONY from The Astute Blogger - a "no nuance zone" hosted by reliapundit
Fixed the link [Read More]

Tracked on October 26, 2004 12:07 AM

» HMXScam from Stones Cry Out
Captain Ed is reporting that the NY Times is continuing to run with the discredited story. Joe Carter has a different angle on HMXScam exposing the NY Times hit piece. [Read More]

Tracked on October 26, 2004 12:32 AM

» NBC vs NYT; KE04 SOL from RIGHT ON RED >>
Q: How do you know Liberal Media Outlet A is shilling for a campaign rather than reporting? A: When a rival Liberal Media Outlet B points it out. [Read More]

Tracked on October 26, 2004 12:50 AM

» NYTimes story and NBC rebuttal from Shouting into the Wind
Read Captain's Quarters for the latest news. First, we started the day with the New York Times story that 380 tons of "highly explosive material" went missing in Iraq. By the time of the evening newscast, NBC had set the record straight - that the m... [Read More]

Tracked on October 26, 2004 12:52 AM

» Hey, about those missing explosives, y'all from Small Town Veteran
So, once again the lame-stream media is trying to find some way to make the Bush administration look bad going into the election. From the New York Times: The Iraqi interim government has warned the United States and international nuclear [Read More]

Tracked on October 26, 2004 2:47 AM

» NBC spanks New York Times from Let the Voice be Heard
This morning I was listening to NPR and they made reference to this missing weapons story 3 times. In two of them... [Read More]

Tracked on October 26, 2004 9:45 AM

Design & Skinning by:
m2 web studios

blog advertising


Proud Ex-Pat Member of the Bear Flag League!